Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Graphic Card Question Buy or Wait?
MSFN Forums > Software, Hardware, Media and Games Central > Hardware Hangout

   
Google Internet Forums Unattended CD/DVD Guide
vegettoxp
Hey Guys, I was just getting read to to buy the Nvidia G-Force 8800GTS 640MB EVGA Graphic Card, but I ran into an interesting article online. It was saying that in Q4 Nvidia plans to release the GeForce 8 Series in PCI-E 2.0 Version. And of course GeForce 9 Series will be PCI-E 2.0 Ready For Sure.

I was just wondering should I get the Graphic Card now or should I wait for the GeForce 8 Series to be PCI-E 2.0. If I have to wait I can wait, but I just wanted to get your guys opinion on this. I just bought me the Samsung 226CW last me and that LCD is off the Hook. I am really having alot of fun with the LCD.

So if you guys can share your opinion on this, it would really help me out. Thank you for all your help.

P.S. Fusion
jcarle
Don't forget your motherboard must be PCI-Express 2.0 as well
Zxian
What I'm wondering is what devices we have today that actually need PCI-E 2.0. Most graphics cards today don't even make use of the 16 lanes that they're given, so why should we need more. From what I understand, PCI-E 2.0 ports will be backwards compatible with current PCI-E, so your graphics card today will work in X38 based motherboards (speculatively speaking).
puntoMX
Plans are that nVidia will release there PCI-E 2.0 cards and chipsets in November.

I don’t think it will make much difference with the first PCI-E 2.0 and the PCI-E cards; you will pay more and get almost no performance gains out of it. Wait some 9 months I would say if you want to go with PCI-E 2.0, but I’m sure you want to use it when the latest games come out in November newwink.gif so I would buy that card when you want it (the no PCI-E 2.0 version), if not now.
brucevangeorge
QUOTE (puntoMX @ Aug 7 2007, 03:32 PM) *
you will pay more and get almost no performance gains out of it.


That's what they said about AGP.
puntoMX
QUOTE (brucevangeorge @ Aug 7 2007, 05:46 PM) *
QUOTE (puntoMX @ Aug 7 2007, 03:32 PM) *
you will pay more and get almost no performance gains out of it.

That's what they said about AGP.

In general all new stuff isn’t interesting when you look at the price performance ratio. I could be wrong but letīs see in November newwink.gif.
ripken204
just get the 8800GTS 640mb. waiting always sucks. i didnt feel like waiting 4-5 more months for the 9800 so i just decided to pick up an 8800GTS 320mb, it was well worth it.
nmX.Memnoch
QUOTE (Zxian @ Aug 7 2007, 04:27 PM) *
What I'm wondering is what devices we have today that actually need PCI-E 2.0. Most graphics cards today don't even make use of the 16 lanes that they're given, so why should we need more. From what I understand, PCI-E 2.0 ports will be backwards compatible with current PCI-E, so your graphics card today will work in X38 based motherboards (speculatively speaking).

There's other enhancements and fixes in PCIe 2.0 then just the bandwidth increases. Notice that we haven't seen any PCIe sound cards yet? There's supposedly a timing/packet overhead issue that PCIe 2.0 corrects and will allow for sound cards to work properly on PCIe.

Now I know you're probably saying "but it's just a sound card!". And while you're right...I'd love to have a system with no PCI cards in it. Think of PCI as the old ISA bus (for those of you old enough to remember that). Right now my system only has one PCI card...and that's my Audigy 2 ZS.

- BFG GeForce 7900GT 512MB PCIe X16
- Intel PRO/1000 PT PCIe X1 NIC
- Belkin FireWire 800/USB PCIe X1 Controller
- Integrated JMicron SATA/PATA PCIe X1 Controller
- Creative Labs Sound Blaster Audigy 2 ZX PCI Sound Card

I kinda lucked out when I ordered my stuff because the Intel PCIe NIC had just hit the market. Everything has it's own dedicated bandwidth thanks the PCIe and only having the one device on the PCI bus.
jcarle
QUOTE (nmX.Memnoch @ Aug 8 2007, 01:19 AM) *
...the old ISA bus (for those of you old enough to remember that)...
I remember IBM's attempt at PCI with MicroChannel Architecture (MCA). Now THAT was something special and rare!
Zxian
@Memnoch - Fair enough. It is a nice thing not to share bandwidth, but I think what most people will emphasise about PCIe 2.0 is the increased speed. It's like everything in this world... FASTER IS BETTER!!! (even when it isn't)

My workstation still has an ISA slot. cool.gif
nmX.Memnoch
To be fair though...the industry was blamed for the PCI bus becoming the choke point when devices started to use more bandwidth. And now that they're trying to stay ahead of the curve they're being blamed for devices not using all of the available bandwidth. So they're damned if they do and damned if they don't. smile.gif

Just because we aren't using the extra bandwidth doesn't mean it's better. Would you rather have more than enough or not enough? Personally, I opt for more than I need in regards to device bandwidth.

I do agree with you though...it'll be heavily marketed just because it's faster, which isn't necessarily the entire reason for the spec change. I view the additional bandwidth as an added bonus. Hopefully this will be what's needed to reverse the current "4xPCI and 2xPCIe X1" slot configuration to something like "4xPCIe X1 and 2xPCI" slot configurations. Maybe we can even start seeing some X4 slots on enthusiast boards. That would be nice for running both SLI/Xfire and a nice true hardware SATA RAID controller. smile.gif
Zxian
Or... we can all get boards like the Wall Street Quartet... laugh.gif

I actually considered that for my file server setup....unsure.gif
nmX.Memnoch
Not bad but that brings me to another point. Why can't they just add enough lanes so that all the slots are electrically X16 instead of splitting it up? You have two options for that board...x8/x8/x4/x8 or x16/x0/x4/x0. Still, it would provide more than adequate performance for current PCIe cards. biggrin.gif
Zxian
Haha - 64 lanes would be sick...

/me wants.
Polarman
I'd wait at least a full year. Leave them time to fix and tune it. All new stuff come with new bugs.
nmX.Memnoch
Errr...this is the "fix" to PCIe. It's not even the first one. Current PCIe motherboards use the 1.1 specification. This one is 2.0...as in an update to an existing technology, not something new.
puntoMX
And there we have PCI-E 3.0. Still we have to wait untill 2010 newwink.gif.
Griefage
i'd personally wait until the pci-e 2.0 comes out, but only for a price break on the pci-e 1.0, thats my plan atleast. seeing $100 drop in a few months on something i intend to use for a few years sucks lol. a video card like that is solid, and if you go the dual video card route, you can get even more life out of that video card.

the new x38 motherboards won't be out for a month or two, and they will support both nvida and ati so you don't have to "pick and choose" your chipset which is great.

wait it out, i think you'd be more satisfied smile.gif
Google Internet Forums Unattended CD/DVD Guide
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.