Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: My IDE and SATA need help
MSFN Forums > Software, Hardware, Media and Games Central > Hardware Hangout

   
Google Internet Forums Unattended CD/DVD Guide
Romeo26222
Hi iam renewing my system and now i have a Gigabyte MB which have only 1 IDE port and i have 2 Hard disks one is SATA and the other is IDE..now i want to ask if i connect the IDE drive with the same cable with the DVD writer drive..and i will make the SATA the system installation drive..will this reduce any speed of my PC? and will this make the burn process slower??
thanx in advance
ripken204
if you are doing anything between the ide and dvd writer, then there will be reduced speeds. this is due to the fact that data can only be sent one way at a time. so yes it will work, but slow. if you wanted to you could get an ide->sata adapter.
Romeo26222
QUOTE (ripken204 @ Nov 23 2006, 04:01 PM) *
if you are doing anything between the ide and dvd writer, then there will be reduced speeds. this is due to the fact that data can only be sent one way at a time. so yes it will work, but slow. if you wanted to you could get an ide->sata adapter.

thanx for your help but if i use an IDE to SATA will the IDE drive be as fast in data transfer as SATA??
uvmain
It will be exactly the same speed smile.gif

it will have the same theoretical throughput as a sata drive, but this is besides the point.. the drive will still transfer data at exactly the same speed.

If you have both an IDE and a SATA drive, your system will place the IDE before the SATA -
IE the only way you can make the sata drive the boot disk and C:/ is to disable the IDE drive before using Windows Setup.

If you use a 'sirilell' IDE>SATA adaptor, then both drives will be seen as sata disks.
Romeo26222
QUOTE (uvmain @ Nov 23 2006, 04:47 PM) *
It will be exactly the same speed smile.gif

it will have the same theoretical throughput as a sata drive, but this is besides the point.. the drive will still transfer data at exactly the same speed.

If you have both an IDE and a SATA drive, your system will place the IDE before the SATA -
IE the only way you can make the sata drive the boot disk and C:/ is to disable the IDE drive before using Windows Setup.

If you use a 'sirilell' IDE>SATA adaptor, then both drives will be seen as sata disks.


thank you so much this is really helped me...
bonestonne
would it also be possibly to connect the IDE as the slave on the chain, allowing the DVD burner to be the master? that way the SATA drive would be the master no matter what, with no interferance, and the DVD drive would have its speed. correct me if i'm wrong though.
uvmain
it doesn't matter if you have your IDE drive on primary master or secondary slave or whatever.. IDE will always come before sata, so your IDE will be C:/ and your sata will be D:/

this annoyed me so much that I stuck My last PATA drive into our downloadserver, and just went all SATA

you can get round it by disabling the PATA drive in bios before installing, and that way your sata drive will be C:/

just remember to re-enable it once windows is installed.. otherwise, even though it is disabled in bios, windows will still see it, but in PIO mode (very slow transfer rates)
that is, unless you disable the IDE channel entirely newwink.gif

Until you can be bothered/can afford another SATA drive, just disable it in bios before an install, install to the SATA C:/, then reenable the drive. This worked for me for the few months where I had both kinds of drive smile.gif


*EDIT*

you could get one of these
http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/SATA-To-IDE-Ultra-AT...bayphotohosting

I've bought computer stuff from this guy before, incredibly cheap, and it works smile.gif
bonestonne
regardless of all the adapters in the world, if the IDE hard drive is a slave, windows wont install on it, because it can't boot off it.
uvmain
1) you're wrong
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AT_Attachment


2) the ide *can't* be a master/slave/anything
with the adaptor.. it'll be recognised as a SATA drive, and sata doesn't even HAVE master/slave

smile.gif
bonestonne
blink.gif i mean install on the SATA first, then have the ODD as the master on an IDE chain, then have the IDE drive as a slave...theres no reason that would cause a problem.
michael_25cm
Which one the CPU reads first, the SATA or the IDE?
ripken204
arnt u able to set the default drive in the bios?
uvmain
QUOTE (michael_25cm @ Nov 25 2006, 04:01 PM) *
Which one the CPU reads first, the SATA or the IDE?


Your IDE drives will be placed infront of SATA drives, no matter how you set the boot drive preferences

QUOTE (ripken204 @ Nov 25 2006, 04:40 PM) *
arnt u able to set the default drive in the bios?


you mean to boot from? yes, of course. but even if you set your bios to boot from a sata drive, it will not be C:/ if you have any pata harddrives in your machine.

If you install onto the sata with the pata disabled, then it will be C:/, and will remain C:/ when you re-enable the pata. but if you boot into windows setup with both PATA and SATA drives enabled, then even tho you will be able to install to the sata drive, you will end up having your system on D:/ or E:/ or however many drives you have.
bonestonne
ok, well if thats the case, then what does it really matter? let your windows drive letter be whatever...its not half as important as the whole system working, right?
puntoMX
QUOTE (uvmain @ Nov 26 2006, 02:30 AM) *
QUOTE (michael_25cm @ Nov 25 2006, 04:01 PM) *

Which one the CPU reads first, the SATA or the IDE?

Your IDE drives will be placed infront of SATA drives, no matter how you set the boot drive preferences


Most BIOSes will detect PATA first over SATA, however you are wrong with your statement and you can choose in most BIOSes where to boot from, it doesn’t mater if it PATA, SATA or even USB-HDD.
ripken204
QUOTE (puntoMX @ Nov 27 2006, 03:41 PM) *
QUOTE (uvmain @ Nov 26 2006, 02:30 AM) *

QUOTE (michael_25cm @ Nov 25 2006, 04:01 PM) *

Which one the CPU reads first, the SATA or the IDE?

Your IDE drives will be placed infront of SATA drives, no matter how you set the boot drive preferences


Most BIOSes will detect PATA first over SATA, however you are wrong with your statement and you can choose in most BIOSes where to boot from, it doesn’t mater if it PATA, SATA or even USB-HDD.

which is exactly what i thought. my bios is prolly one of the best thats out there and has so many options, maybe other bioses just dont have the option.
uvmain
QUOTE
which is exactly what i thought. my bios is prolly one of the best thats out there and has so many options, maybe other bioses just dont have the option.
I have a NF4 Ultra D - the exact same board as you, and I'm using the latest beta bios from DFI street.

Same board as you, and definately the latest and greatest bios..

So no, your board will still act exactly as I said it will, because mine does newwink.gif

QUOTE (puntoMX @ Nov 27 2006, 08:41 PM) *
Most BIOSes will detect PATA first over SATA, however you are wrong with your statement and you can choose in most BIOSes where to boot from, it doesn’t mater if it PATA, SATA or even USB-HDD.


I never said you can't choose which to boot from.. If ripken hits escapre during post, hell, he can choose to boot from an ipod if he wants!
the point was, in the drive lettering, pata gets detected before sata.
I have the same board, and I boot from a raptor, with a pata drive in my sys, but I have to disable to pata to install to the raptor as C:/
ripken204
which raptor do u have? b/c technically the 74gig is a pata with a sata connection, thats why you are able to install OSX on it as an ide drive while sata doesnt work so well..
puntoMX
QUOTE (uvmain @ Nov 28 2006, 02:01 AM) *
the point was, in the drive lettering, pata gets detected before sata.
I have the same board, and I boot from a raptor, with a pata drive in my sys, but I have to disable to pata to install to the raptor as C:/

Yeah, I know. But it’s just a small point of XP. There should have been more options at setup. But you gave the golden tip; Disabling the PATA controller or drive.
uvmain
QUOTE (ripken204 @ Nov 29 2006, 02:05 AM) *
which raptor do u have? b/c technically the 74gig is a pata with a sata connection, thats why you are able to install OSX on it as an ide drive while sata doesnt work so well..


I'm able to install Vista/XP/OSX86 onto any of my sata drives, without any drivers. The latest AMD OSX86 works flawlessly on all my sata drives tongue.gif

37GB WD Raptor
250GB Maxtor DM10
300GB Maxtor DM10
50GB pata MAxtor DM9
Google Internet Forums Unattended CD/DVD Guide
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.