QUOTE (PROBLEMCHYLD @ Jun 8 2006, 03:25 PM)
I just reinstalled 98SE2ME and REGSVR32.EXE installed properly
but at 1st i didn't have it on my system thanx
I think i might have missed some of your points and you might have missed some of mines
what i mean by a (X)tras is
EXAMPLE:
if i wanted to installed Windows Movie Maker,Infared Monitor,etc
I would be forced to install option 3 which changes my UI & its So So buggy which i don't won't at the present time.
But by me using KUP these same files are functional without option 3 installed, meaning i would
like to use these files without being forced to installed option 3 which may cause system conflict errors/instability with the KUP
I hope you understand
this would be a (Xtras) option for 98SE2ME/KUP users.
SORRY BOUT THE LONG FILE LIST
I didn't know if you had test some of those files
Now 98SE2ME users can test the files that you haven't
also a lot of the files i have listed does work on win98SE
that are not included in 98SE2ME
my test method if different from yours i'm sure.
This is how i test
I check every program on my system thats installed to see
if everything is working which it does.
Before and After a new app installation i do the same check
to see if it caused any problems
This is how I am able to detect a problem if any.
Also i installed KUP with 98SE2ME option 3 successfully without Unicode support.YOU MUST NOT INSTALL UNICODE SUPPORT.
Also with option 3 installed the icon arrows reappear, can you fix this.
I apologize if I missed some of your points, but I need accurate terms/grammar/syntax if I am to understand exactly what some1 means, it's just the way my mind works.

These are my thoughts regarding your comments + suggestions...
About WMI...
Thanks for taking the trouble of uploading the WMI files from ME, but it is not necessary. I do have a WinME setup CD [

], and to obtain a full list, all one needs to do is open WBEM.INF from WinME CD [or from %windir%\INF if a WinME install is available] in Notepad, and look at the CopyFiles sections.
Please keep also in mind that in all Win98 editions [98SE included] WMI can only be installed from the internet [MS web update] as an optional component, it is not included on the 98SE setup CD:
http://www.mdgx.com/add.htm#WMIThat's why I did not add the WinME WMI files to 98SE2ME.
I cannot ask users to install WMI from the internet [without which WinME WMI files would be useless] just because 98SE2ME wants to install the WMI files from WinME on their computers.
Think about this for a second: some users may not even have an internet connection [rare cases but true, I know somebody who never cared about the internet, and on whose computer I have installed 98SE2ME successfully] and/or may not want to/care to/worry about install(ing) WMI [for example, I don't care about WMI/WBEM, I always installed it (and then uninstalled it soon afterwards) strictly for experimental/testing purposes].
About the long list of files...
Please see this:
http://www.mdgx.com/98-5.htm#NEVERbecause it contains all WinME files I found to be incompatible with 98SE, and that should never be installed on 98SE OS.
This URL also included in READ1ST.TXT:
http://www.mdgx.com/9s2m/READ1ST.TXTunder the "FAQ" section [which, as I said before, is a must read if you wish to experiment with files other than the ones included in 98SE2ME]:
QUOTE
* I do NOT include here UNtested WinME system files, because I need to make
sure they work as trouble free as possible on as many computers as possible.
ALL WinME system files listed here:
http://www.mdgx.com/98-5.htm#FMEare already part of 98SE2ME option 1 + option 2 and have been already tested
by myself and by other concerned persons [thank you guys].
WinME system files part of option 3 [see "* Option 3:" in "98SE2ME.PIF
COMPLETE GUIDE" chapter further below for complete list] are an entirely
different matter, and require SEPARATE installation + testing.
WinME system files NOT installed by 98SE2ME NOR listed at URL above were MOST
LIKELY found BUGgy and/or INcompatible with Win98 SE OS.
Please see the list of Win98 SE system files that should NEVER be replaced:
http://www.mdgx.com/98-5.htm#NEVERCertain WinME specific components like System Restore (SR) a.k.a. System File
Protection (SFP) a.k.a. Windows File Protection (WFP) or PCHealth/PCHelp (PCH)
canNOT be installed [probably without hex-modding certain files] onto Win98 SE
due to major differences in core, kernel, shell, UI etc system files code.
See "10 WINME OPTIMIZING TIPS":
http://www.mdgx.com/me1.htm#10WOTand "UNINSTALL PCHEALTH + SYSTEM RESTORE":
http://www.mdgx.com/me1.htm#UPHfor more details.
Nevertheless, if you would like to test other system files from WinME Setup CD
which are not part of 98SE2ME on your Win98 SE computer(s), you MUST allocate
enough time for THOROUGH testing of individual files or small groups of files
separately to eliminate as many errors as possible.
The best bet is to "look" inside %windir%\INF\*.INF files using Notepad or
better plain text editor/viewer:
http://www.mdgx.com/toy.htm#TXTand inside ACM/AX/CPL/DLL/DRV/EXE/MPD/OCX/SYS/VXD/etc system files using a hex
or resource editor/viewer:
http://www.mdgx.com/toy.htm#HEXto figure out which files must go together and which internal code depends on
which other file(s) internal code, and ONLY after that test those particular
(groups of) files 1 at a time.
These freeware tools may help determine system files interdependencies:
- Dependency Walker:
http://www.dependencywalker.com/- Process Explorer:
http://www.sysinternals.com/utilities/processexplorer.html- CurrProcess:
http://www.nirsoft.net/utils/cprocess.htmlIf your tests are successful, please post your detailed results here:
http://www.msfn.org/board/?showtopic=46349so we can all benefit.
Just make sure to perform such tests ONLY AFTER installing 98SE2ME system
files from option 2, and eventually option 3 IF tested files are part of
Windows Explorer, Shell + UI Controls, because certain files may DEPEND upon
OTHER [ALREADY REPLACED] WinME system files.
And don't forget to "clone" [backup] your Win98 OS BEFORE experimenting: see
"TESTING... CLONE98.PIF + 98RESTOR.BAT" chapter further below.
This also refers [as stated above] to all who would like to experiment with/test WinME files other than the ones already included in 98SE2ME.
This also states that testing of such files must be done as thorough as possible, by adding small groups of files that depend on each other as listed in the INF files and with examples of tools capable to detect/monitor such interdependencies properly.
Just by testing apps/games/tools/etc with some files [selected using any criteria other than stated here and in READ1ST.TXT] does not prove [validate] nor disproves [invalidates] a file's or group of files' (in)compatibility.
Testing system files with apps/games/tools/etc should constitute only the last step in such experiments.
If you would like to experiment with WinME files on your computer, please feel free, and if you find out that some work properly with 98SE [after testing as described above], please post here your detailed findings so we can all benefit.
IMHO:
A proper experiment should include complete step-by-step instructions on how it has been achieved and all special conditions [if any] necessary for certain files to work properly.
BTW:
Some of the executables you list are DOS tools that work only with WinME [unless you add proper setver lines to your autoexec.bat or if you hex-edit them and/or command.com/io.sys to disable OS version/build check]. Examples:
debug.exe
Deltree.exe
Diskcopy.exe
Doskey.exe
fc.exe
format.com
label.exe
more.exe
sort.exe
subst.exe
sys.com
xcopy.exe
xcopy32.exe
Please understand also that I have been testing WinME files with 98SE OS for over 5 years, which means that I have probably tested most of the files that can be tested in normal conditions on my computer and on a few others.
I cannot test certain files because of specific hardware requirements [examples: LCD monitors, DVI monitors, serial ports, certain printer types, dial-up/analog/winmodem/56k/ISDN/xDSL/satellite modems, digital cameras, USB sticks, webTV, infrared devices, wireless devices, FireWire devices and many others], because I do not have such hardware, therefore proper testing is impossible on my computer.
Other WinME files are binary identical with the ones from 98SE [mscdex.exe].
Others have less/buggy/limited/crippled functionality even if they have newer/higher version numbers.
Others don't matter, because they have identical functionality, like the clip*.* files:
CLIPBOOK.EXE
CLIPBRD.EXE
CLIPSRV.EXE
Others are older [and most likely buggy] than the files that can be installed from MS official/unofficial updates/patches/fixes/etc.
And I can go on and on, but the size of this post is becoming way too huge, and unfortunately my time is limited.
About adding movie maker [MM]...
Just because MM [and/or other few files] work(s) with KUP, doesn't make MM/other files proper candidate(s) for inclusion into 98SE2ME.
Let me explain:
Same as with WMI/WBEM, I can't force anybody to install KUP just because 98SE2ME wants to install MM/other files which work only with KUP installed, regardless if option 3 is installed or not.
And this is valid for all 98SE2ME files + options:
all users must have the choice to install unaltered WinME files which should always work with unaltered 98SE files, because [as I said before and is also stated in READ1ST.TXT] 98SE2ME is only a general purpose replacement package, not a tweak/patch/mod/similar tool/package.
The way I see this, 98SE2ME and SP2 [for example] are for everybody [general purpose]. On the other hand RP, KUP, 98lite are only for a certain "niche" audience [a.k.a. power users, tweakers] willing to experiment with different settings/files/tweaks/mods/etc.
If any1 wants to install KUP/RP/similar tweaks/mods/etc that is their choice, that's why these packages are available separately. Please understand that KUP, RP, 98lite etc have completely different purposes, and should not be mixed with 98SE2ME or SP2 or NUSB or similar packages.
And it is also important to understand that all 98SE users regardless of additional/optional/etc components/upgrades/etc should be able to install as many 98SE2ME options [except option 3, of course] as possible, without having to worry about being required to install anything else before installing 98SE2ME.
How to fix desktop icons overlay:
http://www.mdgx.com/98-5.htm#PSBFHTH