The Pennsylvania Supreme Court is hearing a case brought by Superior Court Judge Jane Ore Melvin who says she was defamed in a chat room. Lawyers for the Judge are demanding that America Online disclose the identity of the person in the chat room.
The person in the chat room made a statement that the Judge lobbied her governor so a friend of hers could become a judge. In order to prove defamation, her lawyers have to prove that she was harmed.
The ACLU and others say that this Judge's challenge is a threat to free speech. They compare anonymous chat on the Internet to pamphlets published by Thomas Paine before the Revolutionary War. Others say anonymity should not protect "slander."
Full story @ MSNBC News Technology and Science
Full Version: Chat Room Anonymity On Trial
wtf? all she had to do was leave the chat.
disturbing and sad 
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.