Welcome to MSFN

Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to contribute to this site by submitting your own content or replying to existing content. You'll be able to customize your profile, receive reputation points as a reward for submitting content, while also communicating with other members via your own private inbox, plus much more! This message will be removed once you have signed in.


gamehead200

Great Interview Question

38 posts in this topic

I got asked this in an interview once so that the interviewer could understand my thought process. The answer is actually extremely simple, but unfortunately, I wasn't able to get the right answer at the time.

Here goes...

You're stranded on an island made entirely of solid concrete (comment: unlikely, but OK) in the middle of the ocean. The island has nothing but trees on it. There is a school of sharks swimming around the island. While you're on one side of the island, a lightning bolt strikes a tree on the opposite side of the island and the tree catches fire. Slowly, but surely, the fire spreads from one tree to the next and makes its way towards you.

How do you survive? :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

oh, have some mercy on those too lazy (and/or impatient) to guess :yes:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What kind of sharks? Not all will attack and eat an unharmed man in the ocean ;). This is a good question, and I've used it along with a few others to "watch" someone's cognitive skills in motion.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What kind of sharks? Not all will attack and eat an unharmed man in the ocean ;). This is a good question, and I've used it along with a few others to "watch" someone's cognitive skills in motion.

Sharks that kill you, obviously. :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You have a solid concrete island, with trees growing on it? My first guess was you wake up from this silly nightmare?

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That's a good question, but not as good as this one.

What kind of bear is best...

But seriously, I would turn that question on the interviewer and have them explain exactly why I should work for them instead of rejecting their job offer and taking a position with their competitor.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you cut all the trees from your end before the fire reaches them. That away the fire will not spread any further... :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

you cut all the trees from your end before the fire reaches them. That away the fire will not spread any further... :)

With what tools? :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Digerati has a good point.

Also, islands are usually round, so walking on the shore/ends would mean you evade the fire and reach the other side where everything has already burned down.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Digerati has a good point.

Also, islands are usually round, so walking on the shore/ends would mean you evade the fire and reach the other side where everything has already burned down.

You risk getting eaten by one of the sharks. :P (Yes, I know the shore is shallow, but this isn't the answer. Good thinking, though). :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In this story's logic, are the following true:

1. Are the treetops high? (do branches start growing near to the ground concrete?) - you could pass below

2. Does the lightning strike out of the blue, or does it start raining (as it usually does)? - obvious NOP :P

GL

Edited by GrofLuigi
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You're stranded on an island made entirely of solid concrete (comment: unlikely, but OK) in the middle of the ocean. The island has nothing but trees on it.

If these two sentences are correct then I am not human. I am an Ent and I'm not alone. We'll extinguish the flames in the water, since the sharks do not pose a threat to me and my kind. :)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Break off a branch to use as protection from the sharks, jump in the water to get totally wet as protection from the fire, get out of the water, run through the fire to arrive safely on the side that's already been burned.

Cheers and Regards

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good answer. :)

Next question:

  • Where would you find fresh water and food on your concrete island? You can't drink saltwater and you have no weapons to kill the sharks for food.

Perhaps it would be better to die quickly through obvious means than slowly due to thirst and starvation. ;)

Edited by 5eraph
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

... but this isn't the answer. Good thinking, though)

Here we have a cognitive problem. :ph34r:

An answer can be either valid or not, but NOT necessarily the one you know.

The teacher in second grade asks to one pupil:

On a tree there are 13 starlings.

A hunter shoots down with one shot 5 of them.

How many starlings remain on the tree?

The pupil:

None, as all the others will fly away, scared by the sound of the shot.

The teacher:

That is not the right answer, but I like your way of thinking.

Then the pupil asks the (female) teacher .....

jaclaz

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In this story's logic, are the following true:1. Are the treetops high? (do branches start growing near to the ground concrete?) - you could pass below2. Does the lightning strike out of the blue, or does it start raining (as it usually does)? - obvious NOP :PGL

The treetops are low enough to the ground that if you were to approach a tree that was on fire, it is likely that you would catch fire. The lightning bolt strikes a tree while its raining. If you're going on the assumption that the rain would extinguish the fire, then you're thinking of a heck of a lot of rain.

You're stranded on an island made entirely of solid concrete (comment: unlikely, but OK) in the middle of the ocean. The island has nothing but trees on it.
If these two sentences are correct then I am not human. I am an Ent and I'm not alone. We'll extinguish the flames in the water, since the sharks do not pose a threat to me and my kind. :)

:lol:

Break off a branch to use as protection from the sharks, jump in the water to get totally wet as protection from the fire, get out of the water, run through the fire to arrive safely on the side that's already been burned.Cheers and Regards

You jump in the water and one of the sharks grabs your branch. What protection do you have from the sharks now? :lol:

Next question:

  • Where would you find fresh water and food on your concrete island? You can't drink saltwater and you have no weapons to kill the sharks for food.

Perhaps it would be better to die quickly through obvious means than slowly due to thirst and starvation. ;)

Let's not think of about long-term survival, just this one situation for now. :)

... but this isn't the answer. Good thinking, though)
Here we have a cognitive problem. :ph34r:An answer can be either valid or not, but NOT necessarily the one you know.The teacher in second grade asks to one pupil:
On a tree there are 13 starlings.A hunter shoots down with one shot 5 of them.How many starlings remain on the tree?
The pupil:
None, as all the others will fly away, scared by the sound of the shot.
The teacher:
That is not the right answer, but I like your way of thinking.
Then the pupil asks the (female) teacher .....jaclaz

Then I guess I didn't phrase the original question as clearly as I should have. Everything I've mentioned above and in my previous posts should clarify the situation now. If something's still unclear, feel free to ask for a clarification.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'd improvise a fishing rod from a tree branch, catch me a shark, then get inside it for protection from the fire.

Given more time, sharks could be stacked up into a shark based shelter, to keep the rain off.

You wouldn't want to eat them though, shark tastes like glue.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Again depending on more variables: shape of the island, wind, rate at which the fire spreads, 'geometry' by which it spreads (radial/perfect circle?)...

I break one branch off, set it on fire and start another fire at the opposite end of the island (not directly oposite - imagine a triangle within a circle - touching point 1 is the thunder fire, 2 is the fire I started, and 3 is where I run to). The two fires should cancel out (burn each other's fuel).

There is a tiny flaw though - at some point I'll need to cross the 'line of fire'. :P

I'm dead, I know... :(

GL

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[...] I am an Ent [...]

:lol:

Next question:

  • Where would you find fresh water and food on your concrete island? You can't drink saltwater and you have no weapons to kill the sharks for food.

Perhaps it would be better to die quickly through obvious means than slowly due to thirst and starvation. ;)

Let's not think of about long-term survival, just this one situation for now. :)

I'm glad I'm an Ent. All I need is the sunlight and the abundant nutrients in the seabed. My long-term survival is covered. :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This reminds me of the olden day of playing D&D and now Gamehead is the Dungeon Master, and I'm in crazy world trying to figure out how I can get the sharks to save me from the fire. :wacko:

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Jump in the water, take my chance with the sharks (have dove with sharks before, there cool, only interested in fish)

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I posed this question to someone else, he said "make a boat out of the trees" and I told him he had no tools. He said "Tom Hanks didn't have tools in Cast Away". I thought Robinson Crusoe was a better idea.

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Given the following new information I have another solution that may be more plausible:

The treetops are low enough to the ground that if you were to approach a tree that was on fire, it is likely that you would catch fire. The lightning bolt strikes a tree while its raining. [it's not raining hard enough to extinguish or prevent the spread of the fire.]

[sharks do not fear tree branches.]

Let's not think of about long-term survival

In this solution let us assume that I'm human in the real world. Further, it is known that trees cannot grow in concrete and that the trees are short as stated above. Therefore, all trees on our concrete island are potted and low enough in mass to be tipped.

The trees are dense enough to prevent a person from walking between them without coming into contact with them. However, since they're densely clustered, I will tip a nearby tree into any burning tree and cause a cascade of falling trees that will clear a path for me to an area of the island that is no longer on fire. Or, to save some trees, I simply tip trees in a line to block the spread of the fire.

I have survived the fire without tempting the sharks until my inevitable rescue by flying eagles. :)

Edited by 5eraph
0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Again depending on more variables: shape of the island, wind, rate at which the fire spreads, 'geometry' by which it spreads (radial/perfect circle?)...

I break one branch off, set it on fire and start another fire at the opposite end of the island (not directly oposite - imagine a triangle within a circle - touching point 1 is the thunder fire, 2 is the fire I started, and 3 is where I run to). The two fires should cancel out (burn each other's fuel).

There is a tiny flaw though - at some point I'll need to cross the 'line of fire'. :P

I'm dead, I know... :(

GL

Believe it or not, your answer is pretty close to the actual answer I was told. But think a bit harder... What would happen if you were to set two fires, both spreading in the same direction and burning at the same rate (ignore geometry for now)? ;)

Given the following new information I have another solution that may be more plausible:

The treetops are low enough to the ground that if you were to approach a tree that was on fire, it is likely that you would catch fire. The lightning bolt strikes a tree while its raining. [it's not raining hard enough to extinguish or prevent the spread of the fire.]

[sharks do not fear tree branches.]

Let's not think of about long-term survival

In this solution let us assume that I'm human in the real world. Further, it is known that trees cannot grow in concrete and that the trees are short as stated above. Therefore, all trees on our concrete island are potted and low enough in mass to be tipped.

The trees are dense enough to prevent a person from walking between them without coming into contact with them. However, since they're densely clustered, I will tip a nearby tree into any burning tree and cause a cascade of falling trees that will clear a path for me to an area of the island that is no longer on fire. Or, to save some trees, I simply tip trees in a line to block the spread of the fire.

I have survived the fire without tempting the sharks until my inevitable rescue by flying eagles. :)

Good work at the assumptions - if I were the interviewer, I'd accept this as a valid answer. :P

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Again depending on more variables: shape of the island, wind, rate at which the fire spreads, 'geometry' by which it spreads (radial/perfect circle?)...

I break one branch off, set it on fire and start another fire at the opposite end of the island (not directly oposite - imagine a triangle within a circle - touching point 1 is the thunder fire, 2 is the fire I started, and 3 is where I run to). The two fires should cancel out (burn each other's fuel).

There is a tiny flaw though - at some point I'll need to cross the 'line of fire'. :P

I'm dead, I know... :(

GL

Believe it or not, your answer is pretty close to the actual answer I was told. But think a bit harder... What would happen if you were to set two fires, both spreading in the same direction and burning at the same rate (ignore geometry for now)? ;)

It crossed my mind (square within a circle; or other polygons). But no matter how many fires I start, I will always have to retreat to an area with trees - and I can't imagine a situation where it won't spread towards me. If I start a fire in the middle, the two fires will cancel each other out on the other side, but 'my' fire will go towards me. :(

It's all about geometry ;)

GL

0

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.