tain, on 30 October 2011 - 05:09 AM, said:
I see that you've fixed it now but I wonder why you didn't just upgrade to ie9 instead of wrestling with the issue? Not that I necessarily endorse ie9 but I've really heard nothing but good things about it from ie users.
tain,
That's a fair question. After reading this, you won't be able anymore to say that you've heard nothing but good things about IE9 from users.
I tried IE9 last year and hated it. It had the least informative UI that I'd ever seen on a browser: no page title across the top for quick verification of the page; no permanent menu bar; no status bar (and if you do manage to bring it back, it has lost most of its functionality); no indication of progress for individual downloads; a ridiculously short address bar that cuts off the end of URLs from view.
In addition, there were a number of (IMO) needless changes to the visual design, such as the lopsidedly large Back button and the relocation of buttons, tabs, and the Favorites. I use the Internet mostly for work and research, and it's annoying to have to discover where all the commands are all over again -- to what end?
I'm aware that tweaks and hacks have been found or developed for many of these issues, but even then you don't end up with a useful status bar, which I rely on to keep me posted on safety matters (SmartScreen filter, protected zone, blocked items, privacy report). I know that you can call these up, but the point is that I'm no longer getting this information at a glance while I'm working, rather I have to stop what I'm doing and take time to click on something to get the information.
Incidentally, anyone inclined to think that my reaction to IE9 was strong, should have seen my wife's reaction. I gave it a shot for three days; she uninstalled her IE9 after 20 seconds.
Afterwards, I came across
this list of features that were removed from IE9 relative to IE8. I don't know about some of the more technical issues discussed there, but I can vouch for the decreased functionality.
So it looks like we'll be staying with IE8 for a while.
--JorgeA
This post has been edited by JorgeA: 30 October 2011 - 11:22 AM