Microsoft has been offering a certain "important" (not "critical") update, KB2730450. Here's the introductory paragraph for the update from the MS page:
The bit about sending anonymous traces to Microsoft "without obtaining explicit user consent" got my alarm bells ringing, and so I unchecked it. As there were two "optional" updates to review as well, I hit the Back button and then looked at the optional updates. But when I hit the Back button from there to return to the general update screen, I noticed that it reported all important updates had been selected!? Huh? I was certain that I'd unchecked this particular update. So I went back in, unchecked it, hit the Back button, and -- once again, it told me I had all the important updates selected for download!!
This article describes an update that lets Windows 8 Release Preview send anonymous traces to Microsoft without obtaining explicit user consent. The anonymous traces contain no personally identifiable information and are used to support the identification and correction of operating system (OS) performance issues.
What's the deal with this? No previous Windows Updates function has worked like this. It's like the process is rigged to get the user to download as many updates as possible, even if you have chosen not to download them automatically. I have enough experience with Windows Updates to know that sometimes they cause more trouble than they fix, and sometimes they require a fix themselves; so for questionable updates I prefer to wait a week or two and watch for reports of trouble. Now I have to be extra careful when reviewing the updates, just to make sure that I don't inadvertently tell it to download something I did not want. Now, instead of being able to go back to the summary updates window, if I desire less than the full selection of updates I have to execute the downloads from the screen for the specific category ("important" vs. "optional" updates).
Another way in which Windows 8 circumscribes the user's scope of action, and channels him/her into doing things Microsoft's way.
I have Windows Updates set to notify before downloading. Is there a way to change the WU behavior for this setting in Win8, to the way that it works in Vista and Windows 7?
P.S. Note that this update behavior doesn't have anything (necessarily) to do with MS's wish to monitor performance issues. I also have the Consumer Preview, and it keeps pushing an Nvidia driver update the same way: if I uncheck it and then return to the summary updates page, the update miraculously shows up as selected once again.
Edited by JorgeA, 09 August 2012 - 10:22 AM.