DG834 Modem Cross-Border
Posted 14 May 2013 - 05:53 PM
I bought three DG834 Adsl modems +Ethernet hubs. The first over eBay.fr worked fine but was destroyed by lightning. The second from eBay.de apparently fails, the third from eBay.de hasn't been tried yet.
They are to work in France, at the computer of my old mother. She understands very little about computers, and I don't access her phone line. She brings the computer for few hours. Not easy...
In the second modem, I introduced the contract's identity and password given by the access provider, as it had worked on the first modem. She has tried the line's autodetection by the modem. She gets the error message "the assistant could not detect the Internet connection" and "please check the DSL cable". Though, all Leds shine.
The setup of the modem wants me to choose a country but proposes only "Germany / others". Could the firmware be specific to each country, needing me to flash it?
Posted 15 May 2013 - 06:03 AM
The "i" led should only shine when the adsl connection is OK.
Edit; there are numerous versions of that "DG834". Check here. For the one I got, the firmware is from 2006 and it's either "UK only" or the rest. Is it possible that your mother didn't plug the cable the right way ? Or After the adsl filter ?
This post has been edited by Ponch: 15 May 2013 - 03:16 PM
Posted 16 May 2013 - 06:10 PM
Looks like your explanation is very close...
First, I believe the line is sound, as well as the filter and the cable, because an other modem, which was not plugged when the stroke hit, works properly from the same connector.
I don't even known if the phone line or the power line propagated the overvoltage, or both. The bolt hit the house next to my mother's, made some mechanical damage there, and many appliances are destroyed in the neighbourhood. The modem's separate power supply looks damaged as well - not too sure as I don't have my lab here, but I've replaced the supply as well.
Meanwhile the attempted microcode update failed. From the same download address you suggest, I got microcodes 5.01.16 and 5.01.09 for the corresponding DG834B V4 ADSL2+, which I chose "for use outside North America and Germany only". The modem rejected the update because "the chosen software does not fit this version". Pity, I had hoped exactly to adapt the modem's operation through the software update.
Maybe an explanation (the English version is less clear):
http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annex_B, also http://de.wikipedia....er-ISDN#Annex_B
Germany uses only ADSL over ISDN according to "annex B", which is physically incompatible with ADSL over analogue telephony according to "annex A". The transmission frequencies differ. A few modems can adapt to both through microcode update and performance loss...
I suppose the DG834 can't adapt through microcode between Annex A and B, which would explain why there is microcode "for Germany" and "except Germany", and the update manager is smart enough to reject a microcode update file not matching the hardware. Though, I'd have wished a note in the manual, and even better, a marking on the box like "works only in annex B countries".
Billions of blistering barnacles! It looks like my nice DG834B from Germany won't run in France.
Other explanations and comments welcome!
Posted 16 May 2013 - 08:34 PM
v5.01.14 "outside North America and Germany only" fails as the previous ones did.
v5.01.14 "for users in Germany and Annex B countries only" is accepted and applied.
Annex B countries are the ones, especially Germany, which have ISDN phone lines (~digital phone) instead of POTS (~analogue phone). ADSL and ADSL2 are similar but use different frequencies and incompatible hardware over ISDN and POTS lines.
Also, my modem is of model DG834B (note the B: to suggest annex B?) while other Ethernet ones are DG834.
doesn't tell directly about the DG834B, but the (wi-fi) DG834GB "has modifications to support Annex-B ADSL".
Googling DG834B hits websites in German only. Especially...
"Dieser DG834 ADSL Firewall Router ist die Annex B Version." (this DG834 is the annex B version)
Looks like I sit in the ink (as they say in German)...
Posted 17 May 2013 - 08:22 AM
"Annexe B" site:netgear-forum.com
returns 300 discussions that tell essentially the same. B is an incompatible hardware meant for the ADSL over ISDN, and these modems work only in countries that follow Annex B: Germany, maybe Austria and parts of Switzerland.
Thundering typhoon! I must get one from a country with ADSL over POTS according to annex A, but as used eBay parts these are quite more expensive.
Posted 17 May 2013 - 09:32 AM
There is no actual difference in the hardware, only the firmware is different (and as a safety measure you cannot flash the "other" one by default).
It may be easy or a litlle more complex if the router is V3 or later.
Check also this:
(There is obviously a risk of bricking the router, but I don't think you have actually anything to lose in trying )
This may be of use (or may be not):
It seems like (but I guess it depends on the version v1, v2, v3, etc.) that loading an earlier firmware (Italian, use google translate):
allows to make the "switch" (and the re-fash the new firmware for the "other" Annex).
You could also try using a Routertech firmware:
- ← USB to Ethernet Adapters and PXE
- Hardware Hangout
- Why is my LCD monitor flickering when coming out of power saving mode? →